Please see the LRC Project Information located under the Course Resources tab.

Self-Defense Laws

Name

Date of submission

What are the four elements of self-defense?

The four elements of self-defense are proportionality, innocence, reasonableness and avoidance.

Discuss each of the elements and describe how they apply to the self-defense justification?

Avoidance. Maryland is a responsibility to retreat jurisdiction, this means that that earlier than using deadly pressure a victim needs to retreat from the chance if he can achieve this properly. No matter the prosecutor’s assertion to the contrary, retreat turned into now not an option here. First, Trujillo became in his very own domestic where there may be seldom a responsibility to retreat. Second, he had protectors inside the residence he couldn't leave by myself with Perez nor marshall them to safety while beneath assault. 1/3, there is by no means a responsibility to retreat if it cannot be completed properly. The situation as defined via Trujillo seemed to enhance very swiftly (Franks, 2016). Retreat become now not a choice. Likewise, faulting Trujillo for not calling the police at an earlier degree of the confrontation, is sincerely Monday morning quarterbacking by using the prosecutor. It's far in all likelihood that it changed into not till he realized how dangerous the state of affairs turned into that Trujillo understood he needed to take action. Had he attempted to name the police without having armed himself, he in all likelihood might have been crushed to a pulp earlier than he ought to have advised the 911 operator what become going on. Under the situations, Trujillo did what he ought to keep away from the scenario by means of leaving Perez, getting his firearm, and standing watch outdoor his youngsters’ door.

Innocence. Perez was the aggressor, he threatened Trujillo’s existence and the lives of his family. Trujillo and his circle of relatives had been harmless.

Proportionality. Trujillo shot Perez as soon as, which stopped him. You're only allowed to apply enough force to prevent the assault. Something in extra, isn't always self-protection, however a criminal offense. With the threat stopped, Trujillo ceased the use of pressure.

Reasonableness. Trujillo ought to moderately finish that Perez changed into able to inflicting death or serious bodily harm. Perez outweighed him by 50 kilos, have been a Marine and studied MMA. Notably, Trujillo knew Perez was a skilled fighter. Reasonableness consists of what you know approximately an assailant, along with their schooling and their violent nature. Normally, you aren't privileged to apply lethal force against an unarmed attacker. The exception is in which there's a disparity of pressure. Standard examples of disparity of pressure include a large guy attacking a smaller man, a man attacking a lady, a healthful person attacking an infirm character, or an educated fighter attacking an untrained person.

What is the “castle doctrine”?

The castle doctrine is the stand your ground laws in Alabama.

What is “stand your ground”?

Stand your ground" is a law that permits people who trust they face an affordable danger of death of remarkable physical damage to "meet force with pressure" rather than retreat from their attacker. Kingdom-enacted "stand your ground" are often used as an allowable defense in crook instances concerning the usage of deadly pressure by way of defendants who literally "stood their ground," in place of chickening out, so that you can defend themselves and others toward real or moderately perceived threats of bodily harm (Humphreys, Gasparrini, & Wiebe, 2017).

A stand-your-ground regulation establishes a proper with the aid of which someone may additionally defend one's self or others (proper of self-defense) in opposition to threats or perceived threats, even to the point of making use of lethal force, no matter whether adequately withdrawing from the situation could have been possible.

How are these doctrines applied in your state?

Beneath Alabama law, you may use bodily pressure in opposition to some other man or woman so one can protect, no longer most effective yourself, but additionally to protect a 3rd individual, from what you fairly trust to be the use or drawing close use of illegal physical pressure via that different individual. In protecting yourself, you could use a diploma of pressure which you fairly agree with is vital for that motive (Humphreys, Gasparrini & Wiebe, 2017). In case you moderately trust that every other man or woman is the use of or is set to use unlawful, lethal physical force towards you or a third individual, you're legally presumed to be justified in using deadly bodily pressure in self-protection or the defense of another individual. You do now not have a duty to retreat, and pursuant to our regulation, you're allowed to stand your ground, supplied you're in an area where you've got a right to be and you are not engaged in an illegal hobby.

References

Franks, M. A. (2016). Safety, Self-Defense, and Stand Your Ground Laws.

Humphreys, D. K., Gasparrini, A., & Wiebe, D. J. (2017). Association between Enactment of a “Stand Your Ground” Self-defense Law and Unlawful Homicides in Florida. JAMA internal medicine, 177(10), 1523-1524.

Humphreys, D. K., Gasparrini, A., & Wiebe, D. J. (2017). Evaluating the impact of Florida’s “stand your ground” self-defense law on homicide and suicide by firearm: an interrupted time series study. JAMA internal medicine, 177(1), 44-50.