debate: Should women be the sole decision maker in the medical termination of pregnancy? YES your support with evidence base research and your experience

Criteria

Unsatisfactory

Competent

Mastery

Total Points

Respect for Opponent

(0-5)
Statements responses and/or body language were consistently not respectful/appropriate

(6-8)
Most statement and responses were respectful

(9-10)
All statements, body language, and responses were respectful and appropriate language was used

/10 

Open Remarks

(5 min)

(0-5)
Information had inaccuracies and all points were not supported

(6-8)
Most information was clear and accurate. Some points were supported. Relevance of some was questionable

(9-10)
All information presented was clear accurate and thorough. Every major point was well supported with relevant facts, statistics, and/or examples

/10 

Rebuttal

(3 min)

(0-5)
Counter arguments were not accurate, relevant, and strong

(6-8)
Most counter arguments were accurate and relevant but several were weak

(9-10)
All counter arguments were accurate relevant and strong

 /10

Opening Floor

(10 min)

(0-15)
Arguments appeared disjointed and not tied in a logical fashion and supported by facts/evidence. .The team did not show adequate understanding of topic

(16-18)
Most arguments were tied to an idea, organized in a logical fashion and supported by facts/evidence. The team understood the main points but did not present with ease.

(19-20)
Arguments were clearly tied to an idea, organized in a logical fashion and supported by facts/evidence. Arguments were presented forcefully and convincingly

/20 

Closing Arguments

(3 min)

(0-15)

All closing arguments were not accurate, relevant, and strong

(16-18)

Most closing arguments were accurate, relevant, and strong

(19-20)

All closing arguments were accurate, relevant, and strong

/20

Time Limits

(0)

Did not meet any time constraints

(1-19)

Met most time constraints

(20)

Met all time constraints

/20

Total Points (100 Points Possible)

 /100