Cyber-Criminality In The Middle East: From Perceptions To Actions: Iraq, Lebanon, Iran, and Saudi Arabia. Thank you for the paper, I appreciate your work and your timely manner. I do have a couple of

1. Why is the literature review only on Saudi Arabia and Iran? In the table of content provided I placed what I wanted in the Lit review: 2.1. Understanding cyber-criminality on a global scale 2.2. Aspects and scope of cyber-criminality 2.3. Types of cyber-crimes 2.4. Types of threats 2.5. Types of responses This is what I wanted in the literature review. this is what my advisor wanted as well that is why I placed this in the document submitted.

2. Just a note (Cyprus is not an Arab country, it’s not even considered to be part of the middle east, it's like Greece)

3. in 1.1 "Additionally, ... human imagination. Cyberspace opportunities. The recent advancement ... manner. " What is “cyberspace opportunities” and why is it a sentence on its own?

4. Where are the perceptions to actions aspect of the proposal in the research question? It’s literally the title