Research Proposal- Gender Based Violence in Pakistan You may need to find some relevant sources as well The timeline of the research should be recent, and the location should be Lahore (city of Pakis

In general, I really enjoyed reading your proposal! It’s very detailed; you’ve clearly put a lot of thought into it and it’s an important topic that hasn’t had a lot of time/resources invested into it.

You asked me to comment on audience appropriateness, organization/structure, and citations/formatting specifically. I’ve left in-line comments throughout your piece, but the big picture feedback I have is

- Is there a reason why you bolded some of your in-text citations? You really don’t need to do that. Also, you reference a source by Abu-Lughod that doesn’t have quotation marks or italics; if it’s a novel title, italicize it and if it’s an article, put it in quotes. You don’t need to bold any of your citations in your bibliography either.

- I think your audience appropriateness is pretty on-point overall, with your tone remaining professional throughout. I did find myself wondering as you went into the details of your planned research, whether you’d be traveling to Pakistan to conduct these interviews and, if so, how you’d cover the travel expenses. In general, I think having a section on how much money you’ll need for this research would be good, since I assume part of the reason you’re proposing this project is to get funding.

- Some of your sections seem a little bit repetitive; I would go back over each and make sure that you aren’t saying anything more times than you need to.

Here are some resources that might help:

- MLA citations

- Sample research proposal

Again, I do think your piece is very well done and just needs some polishing. Good luck with your proposal/IRB review! If you want any clarification or more feedback, feel free to schedule another appointment with me or another consultant. I hope this helped! 

Gender-Based Violence in Lahore, Pakistan: Media Framing, Survivor Narratives, and Institutional Responses

In Pakistan, gender-based violence (GBV) is still a pervasive and deeply ingrained problem that transcends location, class, and educational attainment . Even if institutional solutions are still insufficient, GBV has become more noticeable in Lahore, one of the nation's most populated and culturally vibrant cities. Inspired by these facts, this study uses survivor narratives, institutional practices, and media portrayals to try to understand how GBV is lived, portrayed, and resisted in Lahore. The recent spike in incidents recorded, the increasing momentum of the conversation about women's rights, and the changing role of Pakistani media in influencing public attitudes about gender-based violence all contribute to the urgency of this study.
International narratives frequently oversimplify the lives of Muslim women by portraying them exclusively as helpless victims, but Lila Abu-Lughod's Do Muslim Women Still Need Saving? opposes this representation and promotes a more complex, context-driven interpretation (Abu-Lughod 2013).

Building on her criticism, this study centers the voices of Pakistani women, emphasizing their actions of resistance and navigation within the violent mechanisms that are currently in place. Simultaneously, it seeks to address the dearth of contextualized, grounded research on GBV in South Asia—research that highlights the intricate relationships between politics, religion, law, and culture.
The following major research problems will be investigated by the project, guided by these realizations and gaps in the literature:

Key Research Questions:

1. How do survivors and women’s rights advocates in Lahore understand and respond to gender-based violence in their daily lives?

2. What patterns emerge in the portrayal of GBV across Urdu and English Pakistani media?

3. How do institutions—legal, social, and religious—support or hinder women’s resistance to GBV in Lahore?

Even though gender-based violence (GBV) in Pakistan is receiving more scholarly attention, there is still a big knowledge vacuum about how GBV occurs in intricate metropolitan settings like Lahore because most of the research still focuses on rural contexts or macro-level statistics. The three main scholarly discussions that this study seeks to advance are (1) local experiences and resistance to GBV, (2) how Muslim women are framed in the media, and (3) how feminism, Islam, and state responses connect.
Do Muslim Women Still Need to Be Saved? by Lila Abu-Lughod offers a critical perspective for comprehending how global discourses may simplify Muslim women's lives. She criticizes the propensity to ignore Muslim women's agency and the local systems they interact with in favor of portraying them solely as helpless victims in need of Western rescue.
This criticism is especially pertinent in Pakistan, where similar themes are frequently repeated in the media, either by excluding survivors or by depicting them as defenseless people in need of saving.
Media may be a location for identity formation and resistance, as demonstrated by Jennifer Ashley's ethnographic research on community television in Chile ( Ashley 2007 ).

Despite their different geographic locations and political histories, Chile and Pakistan both have environments where underrepresented voices employ alternative media to subvert prevailing narratives. This is shown in Pakistan, where news stories, social media, and television plays all influence public discussions regarding GBV. Few ethnographic studies, nonetheless, have examined the ways in which advocates and survivors in urban Pakistan understand or react to these stories.
The extent of GBV has been recorded by Pakistani academics and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) like the Aurat Foundation through reports and advocacy campaigns (Aurat Foundation 2019); nevertheless, little is known about how survivors deal with institutional reactions and media discourse on a daily basis. Furthermore, particularly in urban areas like Lahore, there is no connection between the analysis of media content and actual experiences.
When taken as a whole, these sources show the strengths and weaknesses of Pakistan's present GBV policies, emphasizing the need for studies that combine media analysis, institutional critique, and survivor perspectives in a single urban setting. This study fills a key gap in the literature by focusing specifically on the intersection of survivor narratives, institutional responses, and media portrayals in an urban context like Lahore—moving beyond rural generalizations and toward grounded, localized insights.

This research project has three core objectives, each aligned with a specific method and research question:

Objective 1: to comprehend the experiences and reactions of survivors and advocates for women's rights in Lahore to GBV.
Semi-structured interviews with survivors, NGO employees, attorneys, and gender justice advocates will be used to accomplish this goal. The goal is to document both firsthand accounts and expert perspectives on how GBV is seen, opposed, and dealt with in day-to-day interactions. Examining coping mechanisms, institutional obstacles, and support networks are all part of it .

Objective 2: to investigate the portrayal of GBV in Pakistani media, namely in Urdu and English-language publications.
To find recurrent themes, language choices, and visual framing in news stories, television shows, and social media posts, this goal uses content analysis. It seeks to expose the ways in which offenders and victims are portrayed, the kinds of violence that are highlighted or ignored, and the ways in which this coverage supports, skews, or challenges popular narratives on gender-based violence.

Objective 3: to examine how Lahore's legal, social, and religious institutions influence the way people react to GBV.
This aim evaluates the efficacy, accessibility, and constraints of existing institutional frameworks using information from interviews as well as secondary sources (such as government regulations, Aurat Foundation publications, and UN Women reports). It also looks at how legal frameworks and cultural norms clash to influence GBV-related outcomes.

My academic background and personal involvement with feminist discourse in South Asia are the foundations of my interest in studying gender-based violence in Lahore. I have kept a careful eye on the activities of prominent human rights groups in Pakistan, such as the Aurat Foundation (Aurat Foundation 2019), which records incidences of gender-based violence and promotes institutional change. I have also read studies from Human Rights Watch and UN Women, which have helped me better grasp the breadth and complexity of GBV in Pakistan (Human Rights Watch 2021; UN Women 2020).
In order to get ready for this project, I first reviewed the literature on how Muslim women are portrayed in the media, paying special attention to Lila Abu-Lughod's criticisms. My perspective on GBV has been shaped by her work, which views it as a politically and socially located problem that necessitates intersectional and regionally informed analysis rather than as a static cultural phenomenon.
I have also created a thorough methodological framework that includes secondary data collecting, media content analysis, and semi-structured interviews. With the use of these resources, I will be able to generate multifaceted, ethically sound insights into how GBV is seen and combated in Lahore.
I have made informal contact with feminist collectives and community-based organizations in Lahore to help my upcoming fieldwork. These are organizations that provide survivors with media advocacy, psychological counseling, and legal assistance. As the study goes on, this early involvement will help me map the local support landscape and guide participant selection and access tactics.
My academic growth in gender studies, global human rights, and qualitative research is expanded upon by this endeavor. My ability to speak Urdu and English fluently will also make it easier to reach a wide range of participants and media sources, enhancing the research's inclusion and depth.

The second-largest city in Pakistan and a significant center for activism, media, politics, and education is Lahore, where this study will be carried out. Because of its high population density, class variety, vibrant feminist movements, and expanding media coverage of gender-related issues, Lahore offers a complex sociocultural framework for researching GBV. Numerous governmental and non-state organizations that work on GBV issues are also located in the city.

Lahore is a viable location for fieldwork and a strategically important one for comprehending urban GBV in Pakistan because of its accessibility, variety, and institutional presence.

Method 1: Semi-Structured Interviews

Semi-structured interviews will be conducted with three key participant groups:

1. Survivors of gender-based violence

2. Professionals working in support roles (social workers, lawyers, therapists)

3. Gender justice advocates and NGO representatives

Interviews will be conducted in English or Urdu, based on participants’ preference. Interview questions will focus on participants’ lived experiences, their views on institutional support systems, and perceptions of how GBV is portrayed in media.

All interviews will be conducted in accordance with ethical protocols, including:

• Informed consent

• Right to withdraw at any time

• Trauma-informed questioning practices

• Confidentiality and secure data storage

Where relevant, participants may also include members of the Pakistani diaspora or transnational feminist activists working on GBV.

Method 2: Secondary Data Analysis

Secondary data will be collected and analyzed from sources including:

• UN Women reports

• Pakistan Demographic and Health Survey (DHS)

• Aurat Foundation publications: (UN Women 2020; DHS 2018; Aurat Foundation 2019)

• Government crime statistics and court records

This method will help identify:

• Trends in GBV reporting

• Regional disparities

• Socioeconomic factors (e.g., age, class, education)

• Gaps in institutional response and legal protection

All data will be critically evaluated for credibility and limitations, especially in under-researched categories such as marital rape or emotional abuse.
This method will provide a macro-level perspective to complement the lived experiences gathered through interviews.

Method 3: Content Analysis of Media

This method will investigate how GBV is framed within various forms of Pakistani media, including:

• Urdu and English-language newspapers

• Prime-time television dramas

• Social media platforms (e.g., Twitter, Facebook)

• NGO and government-led media campaigns

A purposeful sample of media content from the past 2–3 years will be analyzed thematically, using coding categories such as:

• Type of violence depicted

• Language used to describe victims and perpetrators

• Representation of legal/police involvement

• Cultural and religious framing

This analysis will help determine whether media coverage contributes to victim-blaming, desensitization, or public awareness.

Integration of Methods

This study employs a triangulated qualitative design, integrating interviews, secondary data, and media content analysis. This approach will:

• Center the voices of survivors and gender justice advocates

• Contextualize individual experiences within institutional and societal structures

• Critically assess the discourse that shapes collective perceptions of GBV

This integrative methodology enhances analytical depth and ensures that findings reflect both systemic patterns and personal realities—consistent with feminist ethnography and critical media studies. This triangulated, feminist-interdisciplinary method represents an innovative contribution to gender studies and urban research in South Asia.

This study will follow strict ethical and analytical procedures to ensure the integrity, safety, and credibility of the data collected.

Data Collection and Storage

• All interviews will be recorded (with consent) and transcribed securely.

• Each participant will be assigned a pseudonym to protect their identity.

• Data—including field notes, interview transcripts, and media content—will be stored in encrypted digital folders with restricted access.

• Any physical documents (e.g. printed reports, signed consent forms) will be kept in a locked file cabinet or scanned and stored securely.

Data Analysis

• Interview data will be analyzed thematically using a grounded theory approach. I will code transcripts to identify recurring themes such as institutional trust, survivor agency, religious framing, and emotional impact.

• Content analysis will involve both qualitative (discourse and framing analysis) and simple quantitative coding (e.g., frequency of victim-blaming language or focus on legal justice).

• Secondary data (e.g., DHS reports or Aurat Foundation statistics) will be interpreted using a critical feminist lens to highlight gaps, silences, or institutional biases in the representation of GBV.

Ethical Considerations

• All participants will be informed of their rights, including the right to withdraw at any point.

• Interviews will be conducted with sensitivity and trauma-awareness, especially when working with survivors.

• I will seek Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval before beginning fieldwork, ensuring that all research protocols meet international ethical standards.

The findings of this research will be shared across both academic and community platforms to ensure a wide and meaningful impact:

1. Academic Dissemination

• I plan to present key findings at international conferences focused on gender studies, South Asian politics, or human rights (e.g., ISA, AAS, or Lahore University conferences).

• The research will be developed into a publishable paper for a peer-reviewed journal such as Gender & Society, Feminist Media Studies, or a regional journal focusing on Pakistan or South Asia.

• I may also contribute to edited volumes on gender-based violence or Muslim women’s agency.

2. Community and Local Dissemination

• I will draft an Urdu policy brief outlining the key conclusions and suggestions, which I may distribute to Lahore's local NGOs and legal aid groups.

• With consent, I will work with women's advocacy organizations to present a lecture or workshop for the community on how survivors can deal with institutional structures and how GBV is depicted in the media.

• Short articles or infographics published on websites utilized by Pakistani human rights organizations and feminist networks may also disseminate the findings.

3. Media and Public Engagement

• I will explore writing an opinion piece or blog post for local or international media (e.g., Dawn, The Express Tribune, or openDemocracy) to highlight the implications of the study.

• If possible, I may collaborate with digital storytelling platforms to feature anonymized survivor narratives that emerged from the study (with full consent).

• I also want to create a brief, visually appealing movie (2–3 minutes) in Urdu with English subtitles that summarizes the main conclusions and recommendations for action. The film can be disseminated via partner NGOs and social media sites to increase awareness and initiate public discourse in an approachable and compassionate manner.

Millions of women in Pakistan are victims of gender-based violence (GBV), a widespread human rights violation, yet many parts of it are still misinterpreted , underreported, or misrepresented, particularly in cities like Lahore. Millions of women in Pakistan are victims of gender-based violence (GBV), a widespread human rights violation, yet many parts of it are still misinterpreted, underreported, or misrepresented, particularly in cities like Lahore. The intellectual merit of this research lies in its interdisciplinary integration of survivor narratives, media critique, and policy analysis, offering a novel, context-specific approach to GBV in urban Pakistan.

By challenging reductive portrayals of Muslim women and emphasizing the nuanced agency and resistance in their lived experiences, this study expands the scope of feminist inquiry. It contributes to global debates around decolonizing gender research and aligns with scholarly priorities in gender, media, and postcolonial studies.

Updated Dissemination of Findings (with "Broader Impact" and Deliverables):

This study aims for both scholarly contribution and practical change.

1. Academic Dissemination (Intellectual Merit):

• Journal article in Gender & Society or Feminist Media Studies

• Conference presentations at ISA, AAS, or regional South Asian studies events

• Contributions to edited volumes on Muslim women's agency or gender violence

2. Community & Policy Impact (Broader Impact):

• Urdu-language policy brief with actionable recommendations for NGOs and legal groups

• Workshop or seminar with feminist organizations in Lahore

• Short awareness video (2–3 mins) with Urdu narration and English subtitles for NGOs/social media

• Blog/opinion piece for local media (e.g., Dawn or The Express Tribune)

• Infographics for human rights websites and feminist platforms

These outputs reflect the broader impact of the research by engaging civil society, informing policy, and improving public understanding of GBV in Lahore.

Abu-Lughod, Lila. 2013. Do Muslim Women Need Saving? Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Al Jazeera. 2023. “The Media's Role in Shaping Narratives on Domestic Violence in South Asia.” Al Jazeera, February 2, 2023. https://www.aljazeera.com/.

Amnesty International. 2022. Pakistan: Gender-Based Violence Reports. London: Amnesty International Publications.

Ashley, Jennifer. 2007. Community Television in Chile: Mediating Local, National, and Regional Politics. NSF Project Description. Brown University.

Aurat Foundation. 2019. Annual Report on Violence Against Women in Pakistan. Lahore: Aurat Foundation.

BBC Urdu. 2022. “How Pakistani Media Reports Gender Violence.” BBC Urdu, July 2022. https://www.bbc.com/urdu.

Fraser, Nancy. 1990. “Rethinking the Public Sphere: A Contribution to the Critique of Actually Existing Democracy.” Social Text 25/26: 56–80.

Human Rights Watch. 2021. Shattered Lives: Sexual Violence during Conflict. New York: Human Rights Watch.

Kandiyoti, Deniz. 1988. “Bargaining with Patriarchy.” Gender & Society 2 (3): 274–290.

Lahore Commission on Women. 2021. Policy Brief on Urban GBV Trends in Lahore. Lahore: LCW.

Mahmood, Saba. 2005. Politics of Piety: The Islamic Revival and the Feminist Subject. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Mernissi, Fatima. 1991. The Veil and the Male Elite: A Feminist Interpretation of Women’s Rights in Islam. Reading, MA: Perseus Books.

Mohanty, Chandra Talpade. 1984. “Under Western Eyes: Feminist Scholarship and Colonial Discourses.” Boundary 2 12/13: 333–358.

Pakistan Bureau of Statistics. 2018. Demographic and Health Survey (DHS) 2017–18. Government of Pakistan.

Shirkat Gah. 2020. Women’s Empowerment in Lahore: Challenges and Responses. Lahore: Shirkat Gah Women’s Resource Centre.

Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty. 1988. “Can the Subaltern Speak?” In Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture, edited by Cary Nelson and Lawrence Grossberg, 271–313. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.

The Express Tribune. 2023. “Rising Cases of Gender-Based Violence in Lahore.” The Express Tribune, March 10, 2023. https://tribune.com.pk.

UN Women Pakistan. 2021. Gender-Based Violence and Response in Pakistan: Rapid Assessment Report. Islamabad: UN Women.

World Health Organization. 2021. Violence Against Women: Prevalence Estimates, 2018. Geneva: WHO.

Zia, Afiya Shehrbano. 2018. Faith and Feminism in Pakistan: Religious Agency or Secular Autonomy? Brighton: Sussex Academic Press.