Journal Article Critique #3 No additional details were added for this assignment.RubricJournal Article Critique Rubric DJournal Article Critique Rubric DCriteriaRatingsPtsThis criterion is linked to

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeBibliographical Entry

5 ptsTargetThe bibliographical entry adheres to APA style completely

4 ptsAcceptableThe bibliographical entry adheres to APA style mostly

3 ptsEmergingThe bibliographical entry does not adhere to APA style

0 ptsUnacceptableNo bibliographical entry.

5 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeSynopsis or Summary of the Reading

5 ptsTargetSynopsis demonstrates a thorough understanding of the article by listing key findings and reflecting upon their implications.

4 ptsAcceptableSynopsis demonstrates some understanding of the article with few key findings reported

3 ptsEmergingSynopsis demonstrates little understanding of the article with few key findings reported.

0 ptsUnacceptableSynopsis demonstrates no understanding of the article.

5 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeOpinion or Evaluation of Usefulness of Content

5 ptsTargetThe opinion or evaluation of the article is given and supported with details.

4 ptsAcceptableThe opinion or evaluation of the article is given but not supported with details

3 ptsEmergingThere is little opinion or evaluation of the content.

0 ptsUnacceptableThere is no opinion or evaluation of the content.

5 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeMechanics

5 ptsTargetThe product used complete sentences and appropriate grammar, has no major spelling errors or APA errors

4 ptsAcceptableThe product has some spelling, grammar, and/or APA errors.

3 ptsEmergingThe product has many spelling, grammar, and/or APA errors.

0 ptsUnacceptableThe product is not an appropriate product of doctoral level work.

5 pts