for michael smith only

Ethical Theories Comparison Chart

Utilitarianism

Ethical Egoism

Ethics of Care

Kantianism

Prima Facie Duties

Divine Command Theory

Virtue Theory

How is “good” Determined

Good is determined by consequences

Good is determined by self-interests

Good is determined by the interpersonal care, as the virtue of morals

Good is not determined by actions but consequences

Good is based on the prime duty

Good is determined by the Divine Command

Individual characters led to consequences

Most Noted Philosopher(s)

Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill

Thomas Hobbes

Carol Gilligan and philosopher Nel Noddings

Immanuel Kant

W. D. Ross's

Thomas Aquinas, Robert Adams, and Philip Quinn.

Plato and Socrates

Major Strengths

It provides answers to the question “what ought man to do”

The theory impacts self-confidence and reliability in decision making

The theory helps one to engage in self-examination and determine moral virtues

A persons actions determine his/her moral worth

It guides one to develop moral obligation for his actions

Good is based on faith and beliefs

The theory provide ethical grounds for moral thinking

Major Weaknesses

The theory does not explain the certainty of trust and self-confidence.

According to critics, the theory involves a slave morality and a lot of ambiguity.

The theory create indifferences in others opinions in regard to morality

Not all good actions led to good consequences

The theory fails to elaborate on the cause of action due to incomplete duties

The feasibility of good depends on faith and thus invisible.

It is difficult to establish the nature of virtues depending on their culture and societies.