Week 2: Student Response To Discussion 1 & Discussion 2

Discussion 2

Christopher Tremallo

3/2/2017 5:03:02 PM

6. He broke the record for rushing yards in a game on that last play. Therefore he holds the record.

P1: The rushing record for a single game is 250 yards

P2: He currently has 249 yards rushing in this game.

P3: He just rushed for 2 yards.

P4: He broke the record for rushing yards in a game on that last play.

C: Therefore he holds the record.

The way that the conclusion follows the premise is that we explained what the record is currently and then we established that he ran for more yards than the current record, hence the conclusion that states he is now the new record holder.

Reflection on Premises:

All the premises state facts so they are likely to be true.