must be original


Category

Scoring Criteria

Total Points

Score

Part 1: Emerging Threats Report for the Scientific Community

Basic Outline

(11 points)

Cover page with appropriate text

.50

Table of contents that contains all the prescribed sections of the report

Clear and concise executive summary

Emerging/Re-emerging Infectious Disease Threat Section contains the following:

  • Name of disease

  • Pathogen type

  • Type of disease

  • Case rate

  • Mortality rate

  • Source of infection

  • Treatment options

  • Contributing factors

  • Signs & Symptoms

  • Transmission

  • Prevention

  • History of pandemics

  • Anatomic location

  • Country of origin

Includes a table titled “Major factors that underlie disease emergence and re-emergence” containing:

  • Microbial Agent

  • Human Host

  • Human Environment

.50

Includes a table titled “List of Emerging and Re-Emerging Diseases” containing:

  • Group 1 – Pathogens newly recognized in the past 2 decades

  • Group 2 – Re-emerging pathogens

  • Group 3 – Agents with bioterrorism potential broken down into category A, B, C

.50

Part 2: Emerging Threats Report for the Policy Community

Contains a section for Description/importance of the topic in terms of policy

.50

Contains a section for Existing policies related to topic with subheadings:

1. U.S. policies and procedures for emerging and re-emerging diseases

2. U.S. policies and procedures for biological agents and toxins

.50

Contains a section for agencies/organizations related to topic and how each entity combats the problem

.50

Contains a section for key issues with 2 subheadings:

1. Burden of emerging/re-emerging infectious diseases

2. Threat of emerging/re-emerging infectious diseases

.50

Contains a section for 3 recommendations and implications/possible outcomes of specific courses of action related to recommendations

.50

Contains a section for a conclusion

.50

Reference Page

.50

Organization/Structure

(4 points)

Outline has a clear organizational structure with flow of thought

Outline is effective with logical transitions

Outline contains a professional format

Score

Total Points

15