Journal of the Society of Architectural
Article Form | Name: | Email Address: | Date: | |||||
Maass’s Issues | Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians | |||||||
a. Author: | ||||||||
c. Title of article: | ||||||||
d. Volume: | e. Number: | f. Year: | g. Month: | h. Pages: | ||||
0. What is the primary argument of the article? | ||||||||
1. Bourgeois Standard | 1. Does the article address “nonpedigreed architecture” or architecture that is “vernacular, anonymous, spontaneous, indigenous, [or] rural?” If yes, explain. | |||||||
2. Racial Bias | 2a. Who designed, built, and used the architecture under discussion? (What is significant about the identity of the people in terms of nationality, ethnicity, race, or religion?) | |||||||
2b. Does the article address “non-Western” architecture? | ||||||||
3. Beaten Path | 3a. Where is the architecture under study? | |||||||
3b. Is the architecture located outside of Western Europe? (Western Europe includes European countries to the west of the iron curtain). | ||||||||
4. Genteel Tradition | 4a. What type of building(s) or space(s), does the article address? | |||||||
4b. Does the article address industrial buildings such as gas stations, textile factories, or grain elevators? | ||||||||
5. Surface Treatment | 5. Does the article address materials, structure, building systems, or construction processes? If yes, explain. | |||||||
6. Isolated Building | 6. Does the article discuss the relationship between the architecture and its site or larger context? If yes, explain. | |||||||
7. Isolated Art | 7. Does the article address interior design, painting, or sculpture associated with the architecture? If yes, explain. | |||||||
8. Isolated Discipline | 8a. Does the article author employ scholarship or methods from other disciplines? If yes, explain. | |||||||
8b. Does the scholarship of the article(s) contribute to other disciplines? If yes, explain. | ||||||||
9. What biases does the author reveal that relate to Maass’s criticisms? | ||||||||
10. Summarize your analysis in 150-250 words. What is notable about this article according to the criteria set out by Maass? (Double space this section only.) | ||||||||
11. After going through this exercise, what other significant issues come to mind that Maass does not address? | ||||||||
12. What have you learned about yourself and architectural history? |
8/14/2019