Name: AltaText Book: Human Resource Management – Gaining a Competitive Advantage 10eResearch Paper Selection My research paper selection topic is:Interviewing Methods in the Selection ProcessI have

February 24, 2012 The Central New York Business Journal 9 Personality Testing:

Don't Hire Without it "Having the most talented people in each of our businesses is the most important thing. If we don't, we lose." —Jack Welch while CEO ofGE "If you don't invest the time to do it correctly today, you will spend more time and money in repairing mistakes tomorrow.

" — Don Paullin W ould you describe your employ- ees as Google-y, Appleish, or Microsoft-esque? In other words, what do you know about the personalities that drive performance in your workplace?

Studies on personality assessments as pre- dictors of job performance consistently dem- onstrate their merit, confirming a significant improvement in job match when a personal- ity assessment is administered.

Companies that invest in personality test- ing are some of the most successful in the world. One Internet search giant, for exam- ple, tests for "Googliness" through a battery of 300 questions.

Despite the proven success of personality tests, many hiring protocols still do not include them.

Do you ever ask yourself, what are the ideal traits for your company or for a par- ticular job?

A typical hiring process goes something like this: The company writes a vague job description, applicants respond, screening takes place (usually by someone with little or no training in how to do it and with no pre- scripted questions), in-person interviews are conducted, and the firm hires an applicant.

The trouble is, the applicant has about a 50 percent chance of being a great hire.

A better hiring process goes something like this:

1.

A desired personality is crafted using a personality assessment If possible, suc- cessful employees in the same position are assessed, and the benchmark is created using their results.

2.

A clear job desc-riplion is written and includes the skills and competencies re- quired.

3.

Resumes and applications are screened.

4.

Careful recruiting begins with meticu- lous attention to the desired competencies, skills, and personality traits required.

5.

Telephone screening is done using carefully scripted interview protocols de- signed for the position.

6. j'^plicants chosen for interviewing are asked to complete a personality profile to see how they wiU fit with the culture of the company and the position.

7.

Profiles are scored and applicants are scheduled for interviews.

8. At least two interviewers are involved, and sometimes a panel of interviewers is used.

9. Components of the interview include:

a introductions and rapport building; b.

a careful résumé review, which means looking carefully at education and job his- tory using a structured interview protocol carried out by well-trained interviewers; c. areview of the personality profile to ver- ify its accurac-y and deepen understanding of the applicant's strengths and weaknesses, and to see how close they come to the pro- files of people who are currently successñil in the position; and d. discussion with the candidates about the job and any questions they might have.

10.

The final team meeting to choose the best candidate takes place. Further inter- viewing might be reqtiired to clear-up any questions or concerns.

11.

Carefully scripted reference interviews are conducted.

12.

An applicant is hired.

13.

The applicant has about an 80 percent to 90 percent chance of being a great hire.

Overrule the results of the profile at your own risk.

It is more common than not after a new hire does not perform well that the hiring team looks back and sees things that it missed or ignored in the profile.

Example: John was the lead candidate for a VP of sales position with a salary of $130,000 plus bonuses. He had good experi- ence (verified) as a salesperson and some experience as a sales manager (not well veri- fied). Nonetheless, he made it through the screening steps and reached me for a final review of his personality profile.

He did not quite fit the well-designed benchmark we created for a sales man- ager, but did fit a sale&only benchmark.

Specifically, he came out as relatively im- patient, not attentive enough to analytic thinking, not very detailed, and pretty poor at managing his time and priorities — traits often found in salespeople but usually de- railing characteristics in a sales manager.

Here was one of the cautionary notes in his profile report: "May not pick up on other THOMAS WALSH CLOSELY HELD BUSINESS employees' moods, wants, or needs; may not be patient with oth- ers or tasks; may tend to procrastinate; may not follow through with paperwork." This sales-recruit's personality match was only 70 percent for the success benchmark we used. However, the team loved him and was anxious to fill the position and move on.

John was the best can- didate the company had, and it chose to hire him rather than continue the search. Within four months, it was clear that the profile (and interview verification) was correct. He was simply the wrong hire, and our coach- ing was not enough to compensate — not all salespeople make good sales managers.

We threw away a ton of money, made the hiring team look bad, demoralized the sales team, and John had to look for another job; all because we did not pay attention to our well-devised protocol.

It is almost always a bad move to settle for a mediocre fit You would not choose a spouse based on "so-so" compatibility, nor should you choose an employee, with whom you may work for decades, based on a so-so fit Everything you do should be to get the best possible hire for each and every position.

Thomas Walsh, Ph.D. is president of Grenell Consulting Group, a regional firm specializ- ing in maximizing the performance of closely held organizations and their key contributors.

Email Walsh at [email protected] Sign Up for Our News Alerts DAILY NEWS ALERT Every afternoon, The Business Journal packages a few of the day's most important news stories written by our staff and transmits them via email to 12,000 business people. The news roundup is well received by this audience, because of its convenience and timeliness and because our readers rely on our professional level of journalism.

COFFEE-BREAK ALERT Each morning. The Business Journal emails 12,000 executives a business-news review. The coffee-break alert contains an aggregation of business stories, garnered from a variety of sources and grouped by topic: New York news, U.S.A/Vorld news, and Opinion. Copyright of Business Journal (Central New York) is the property of Central New York Business Review and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.