Assignment 2: Introduction and Revised PICOT QuestionRevise your PICOT question on the basis of the feedback you received on Week 3 Assignment 2. Submit your introduction and revised PICOT question as
Evaluation Table— The Practice of Monitoring Sleep Duration to Aid in Weight Loss
First Author (Year) | Conceptual Framework | Design/Method | Sample and Setting | Major Variables Studied (and Their Definitions) | Measurement | Data Analysis | Findings | Appraisal: Worth to Practice |
Kobayashi, et al., 2012 | none | 3 year Retrospective cohort study | 21,469 healthy adults > 20 yrs with BMI > 25 and weight gain who presented for health checkups; Tokyo, Japan | BMI, sleep duration, weight gain | Self reported average nightly sleep duration | Regression analysis | < 5 hrs sleep per night may facilitate weight gain; optimal duration to mitigate weight gain is 7 hrs | Strengths: size, length of study Weaknesses: Japanese population only; no qualitative data (sleep habits, quality), potential confounder: OSA; 7,649 not included in analysis due to loss data |
Alfaris, et al., 2015 | none | 2 year RCT | 390 obese (BMI 30-50) men & women divided in 3 weight loss intervention programs (differed in consultation intensity); University of Pennsylvania | Sleep duration and quality, mood, BMI, weight | PSQI survey; Patient Health Questionnaire-8 (PHQ-8) mood assessment; administered at baseline, 6 and 24 months | P value | losing 5% of initial weight is associated with short-term improvement in sleep duration and quality & favorable short- and long-term changes in mood | Favorable results in all 3 intervention groups; 1/3 to 1/5 of all 3 groups lost 5% of initial weight Strengths: 86% retention rate Weaknesses: absence of larger mean weight losses |
Knox, 2015 | none | Systematic review | 67 studies narrowed to 2 (RCT and cohort) | Sleep duration and quality, BMI, weight | PSQI survey, BMI, weight | P value, RR | Inconclusive; whether PCPs should emphasize sleep in the treatment of obese patients remains unanswered | Strengths: Higher level data Weakness: Only two studies |
Coughlin & Smith, 2014 | none | Thematic review of four 2008 systematic review | 4 systematic reviews | Sleep duration, BMI, weight | Self- reports, PSQI | Pooled analysis, OR | Support for an association between short sleep duration & weight gain | There is good experimental & substantive longitudinal data linking short sleep to increased weight gain & obesity as well as to behaviors implicated in weight gain |
Filitrault, et al., 2014 | none | RCT, dietary intervention of 12-16 weeks | n = 150 with avg BMI 33.3 | BMI, anthropometric measurements, eating behavior traits (Three-Factor Eating Questionnaire), PSQI score & sleep duration @ baseline & post intervention | Self reports, PSQI | P value | changes in strategic dieting behavior were constantly negatively associated with changes in body weight and fat mass (P<0.05) for recommended duration sleepers | Eating behavior traits & sleep may act together to influence the outcome of weight-loss programs |
OSA: obstructive sleep apnea PSQI: Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index
References
Alfaris, N., Wadden, T., Sarwer, D., Diwald, L., Volger, S., Hong, P.,…Chittams, J. (2015). Effects of a 2-year behavioral weight loss intervention on sleep and mood in obese individuals treated in primary care practice. Obesity, 23, 558-564. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/oby.20996
Coughlin, J. & Smith, M. (2014). Sleep, obesity, and weight loss in adults: Is there a rationale for providing sleep interventions in the treatment of obesity? International Review of Psychiatry, 26(2), 177-188. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.3109/09540261.2014.911150
Filiatrault, M., Chaput, J., Drapeau, V., & Tremblay, A. (2014). Eating behavior traits and sleep as determinants of weight loss in overweight and obese adults. Nutrition and Diabetes, 2014(4), 1-8. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nutd.2014.37
Knox, K. (2015). Should primary care physicians address sleep to improve weight loss in obese patients? A Clin-IQ. Journal of Patient Centered Research and Reviews, 2015(2), 197-200. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.17294/2330-0698.1205
Kobayashi, D., Takahashi, O., Deshpande, G. A., Shimbo, T., & Fukui, T. (2012). Association between weight gain, obesity, and sleep duration: A large-scale 3-year cohort study. Sleep and Breathing, 16(3), 829-33. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11325-011-0583-0
Page 4 of 4
NSG8100 Capstone in Applied Practice I
©2014 South University