Answered You can buy a ready-made answer or pick a professional tutor to order an original one.
Description compare and contrast these 2 ideas 1-idea The ethical cases arising from her wish to quicken her death after being diagnosed with Dementia include; interfering with a cognitive person's ab
Description
compare and contrast these 2 ideas 1-idea The ethical cases arising from her wish to quicken her death after being diagnosed with Dementia include; interfering with a cognitive person's ability to make decisions and Caregivers leaving their patients to die. Though Margaret was diagnosed with Dementia, the judge argued that the fact she could open her mouth to accept food shows that her cognitive abilities were still functioning and that her ability to make decisions could not be passed to a third party. The fact that her family wanted her wishes to be fulfilled would mean that her caregivers would have to do a poor job to lead her to die faster and that is not ethically allowed as they are required to give their best care. 2-idea The ethical issue that arises is that the family wanted to respect Margaret’s wishes, but the nursing home refused as they believe she still wants to eat. The family believes she does not. The nursing home reported when the spoon is lifted to Margaret’s mouth, she opens her mouth. The bioethicists have mixed reviews on the case as well. Are the Margaret who was compos mentis and the Margaret who is hungry and responding to a spoon to the mouth different? These bioethicists believe that the autonomy of Margaret with Alzheimer’s needed to be respected. On the other hand, others are questioning if Margaret has a reflex to having a spoon brought to her mouth. Is she just responding to the movement? “It is important to promote a culture of ethics in the daily professional practice, considering the codes as a compilation of laws or regulations that govern human relationships, assuring people their rights, but also listing their duties.”(Nunes da Silva et al., 2017). Both sides, the family and nursing home bring valuable evidence to the case. It’s hard to state what the answer actually is.
- ANSWER
Compare and Contrast
Patients should make their dying wishes if they are mentally sound to do so. Caregivers and family members can decide on the patients' behalf if the patients lack the cognitive abilities to do so. Regarding the two Ideas, they compare and contrast. On similarities, Idea 1 and Idea 2 depict that the two patients want their families and caregivers to respect their wishes to die. Also, the families of the two patients show determination in respecting the wishes of the patients. Besides, the two patients would open up their mouths to eat, which indicated they had cognitive abilities and capable of making their own decisions. Moreover, the testing of the ability of the patients’ decision-making ability entails testing whether they are capable of eating.
On the other hand, several differences exist between the two Ideas. Regarding Idea 1, for instance, the family does not believe she is incapable of eating, although the reverse is the case for Idea 2. Also, on Idea 1, caregivers just leave their patients to die, which means they are not concerned about the patient’s welfare. However, concerning Idea 2, the nurses report the patient is capable of opening her mouth to eat, meaning they are concerned about her welfare. Moreover, The caregivers in Idea 1 do not respect the autonomy of the patient and would deem it appropriate to allow the patient to die faster. Nonetheless, the bioethicists in Idea 2 believe in respecting the autonomy of the patient. Besides, the caregivers in the two scenarios are different in terms of their approach to their patients, with those in Idea 1 focused on ensuring the patient dies faster while those in Idea 2 want to sustain the life of the patient.