Waiting for answer This question has not been answered yet. You can hire a professional tutor to get the answer.
Suppose Mary is locked from birth in a black and white room where she learns all the physical facts. The rest of this version of the knowledge...
9.
Suppose Mary is locked from birth in a black and white room where she learns all the physical facts. The rest of this version of the knowledge argument goes...
A
She learns something new when she goes outside and sees a red rose--what it's like to see red--therefore what it's like to see red is not a physical fact.
B
She learns something new when she goes outside and sees a red rose. She learns about the shape of the rose. Therefore the shape of the rose is not a physical fact.
C
Both of the answers above are correct.
D
She learns something new when she goes outside and sees a red rose, therefore this must be the first time she has seen a red rose.
