I need help to briefly summarize r the piece by Justin Kaplan, then discuss what you take to be the strengths (if any) and weaknesses (if any) of the...

I need help to briefly summarize r the piece by Justin Kaplan, then discuss what you take to be the strengths (if any) and weaknesses (if any) of the author's argument. Which points do you find persuasive, and which ones less so? With which points do you agree and with which do you disagree?